Please help me out here! :D
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0d67e/0d67ec0287b21068452ae8225625bf38fa3eeb87" alt="Please help me out here D class="
I see no reason for the aluminum foil to have lost any volume, matter, mass , etc.
If all pieces are retrieved for measuring. - &
If a clean cut was achieved- and the blade used to cut did not impede upon the proceedings by also being variable, then I reiterate that there should be no difference in volume, matter, mass, etc.